Arkansas Sens. John Boozman and Tom Cotton helped stop President Donald Trump’s nominee for a seat on the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, prompting the White House to withdraw the nomination and put forward Arkansas Supreme Court Justice J. Cody Hiland instead.
The change came as Trump and Senate Republican leaders sought to advance judicial nominees during the Senate’s lame-duck session before Democrats take control of the chamber. Republican senators have generally supported the president’s judicial selections during his second term, confirming 57 nominees to lifetime positions on federal district and appeals courts, according to Reuters.
The White House withdrew U.S. District Judge Lee Rudofsky’s nomination to the St. Louis-based 8th Circuit on Tuesday. Rudofsky’s nomination was replaced by Hiland’s after Boozman and Cotton opposed the selection. Senators traditionally participate in choosing federal judges for vacancies in their states.
“We put up a lot of really qualified candidates that we sent to the White House, and they basically ignored that and just put through their one,” Sen. Alan Armstrong, an Oklahoma Republican, said.
Home-state senators can have particular influence over trial-court nominees through the Senate Judiciary Committee’s “blue slip” practice. A blue slip indicates a home-state senator’s support for a nominee. Senators can prevent a district-court nomination from moving forward by withholding the form, although the White House has sometimes selected conservative nominees over objections from Republican senators.
Republican opposition
Several Republicans have challenged or questioned nominees selected for vacancies in their states. Outgoing Republican Sens. Thom Tillis of North Carolina and John Cornyn of Texas can deny some nominees the votes needed to advance through their positions on the Judiciary Committee. Armstrong and Cornyn have withheld public support for two nominees in their states, while Tillis has used his committee position to help block candidates opposed by fellow Republicans.
- 57 Trump judicial nominees have been confirmed during his second term, according to Reuters.
- Rudofsky’s nomination was withdrawn from consideration for the 8th Circuit on Tuesday.
- Hiland was selected to replace Rudofsky after Boozman and Cotton opposed the nomination.
The 8th Circuit is based in St. Louis and hears appeals from federal courts in Arkansas and several other states. The dispute over the nomination illustrates the role home-state senators can play in judicial selections even when their party controls the White House and Senate.