A lawsuit over hunting access and property boundaries along the St. Francis River has put a duck-hunting permit lottery under scrutiny as Arkansas’ waterfowl season gets underway.
The St. Francis Lake Association filed suit over the lottery, arguing that the process improperly excludes many hunters who use the area. The group is asking a court to establish the boundary between state property and land controlled by the Hatchie Coon Hunting and Fishing Club.
The dispute involves a section of northeast Arkansas where public hunters and members of a private hunting club use adjoining wetlands. The lottery was held for duck-hunting permits, and the club’s property rights have become central to the association’s challenge.
What the lawsuit seeks
The association says the permit draw would restrict access for a large share of the public hunters who use that part of the St. Francis River. Its lawsuit seeks a judicial decision defining which areas belong to the state and which are part of Hatchie Coon’s property.
- The St. Francis Lake Association filed the challenge over the permit lottery.
- The group wants a court to determine the state-private property boundary.
- The controversy involves duck hunters using wetlands along the St. Francis River.
The matter has also drawn attention to Arkansas Game and Fish Commissioner Chris Caldwell, who is described as a longtime friend of Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders and a former lobbyist for Hatchie Coon. The club is a nonprofit organization based in Memphis, although its hunting property is in Arkansas.
Two association members previously held leadership positions in Hatchie Coon. Tobey Duncan of Trumann served as the club’s president, and John Stuckey of Trumann served as vice president. Stuckey said he left the club in 2019, while Duncan said he left in 2021.
“Individually, there are some nice guys in there. But collectively, it’s a good ol’ boys club, and for whatever reason, they want it to be a Memphis club. It has been historically.”
Duncan said that about Hatchie Coon and its history.
A long-running property dispute
Property-rights disagreements involving Hatchie Coon have existed for more than a century. The club was founded in 1884 by Memphis sportsmen who separated from the Oak Donnick Hunting Club, according to Duncan. Friction between Arkansas residents and Memphis members has continued through the club’s history, he said.
The current dispute concerns access during duck season, which began Saturday. The lawsuit places the boundary question before the court while hunters use the river and surrounding wetlands under the state’s waterfowl regulations.
The Arkansas Game and Fish Commission’s role in issuing or overseeing access permits makes the case a public-policy issue as well as a private property dispute. The court’s consideration will address the boundary asserted by the association and the effect of that boundary on hunters seeking access to the area.