A federal judge has rejected a proposed settlement between Oklahoma and 11 Northwest Arkansas poultry companies in a long-running case over pollution in the Illinois River, setting up a potential appeal to the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
U.S. District Judge Gregory Frizzell of Tulsa issued the ruling Wednesday, Nov. 18, while denying a motion to vacate his earlier judgment and approve the settlement. Oklahoma’s attorney general’s office sued the companies in 2005, alleging that poultry operations contributed to pollution in the river.
A case pending for more than two decades
The case went to trial in 2009. Frizzell later ruled in Oklahoma’s favor in early 2023, after a delay of 13 years between the end of the trial and his decision. The judge then imposed penalties that Oklahoma and the defendants described in joint court filings as “inquisitorial” and unworkable.
Oklahoma subsequently reached settlement agreements with the defendants. Both sides told Frizzell that they would seek approval of the settlement from the 10th Circuit if he rejected it.
“Defendants have litigated this case in such a protracted manner as to monopolize the judicial resources of this court for years, often for the sole purpose of delay.”
Frizzell wrote that passage in his order rejecting the settlement. He also questioned Oklahoma’s timing in pursuing the agreement, writing that the decision appeared to reflect political considerations.
“As for the State, the timing of plaintiff’s decision to settle suggests the influence of political pressures over substance,” Frizzell wrote.
Political changes in Oklahoma
The lawsuit was filed by then-Oklahoma Attorney General Drew Edmondson, who was term-limited out of office shortly after the 2009 trial ended. Four attorneys general later, not counting interim appointments, Frizzell issued his ruling nine days after Gentner Drummond took office as Oklahoma attorney general.
Drummond later entered settlement agreements with the defendants while running unsuccessfully for governor in Oklahoma’s Republican primary against Mike Mazzei, who is now governor-elect. The dispute had become a political issue in southeastern Oklahoma, where poultry farmers blamed Drummond’s pursuit of the case for threatening their livelihoods.
The defendants previously warned that a rejection would lead to an immediate appeal. The parties’ joint filings also said they would ask the 10th Circuit to approve the settlement after a rejection in the district court. The appellate court, based in Denver, has jurisdiction over federal appeals from Arkansas, Oklahoma, New Mexico, Colorado, Wyoming, Utah and Kansas.
The case remains at the federal appellate stage unless the parties take the announced step of seeking review. The judge’s Wednesday order leaves the earlier judgment and the disputed penalties in place while the litigation continues.